First-time homebuyers play a crucial role in New Yorks housing market.
In recent years, however, they have faced steep challenges.
High prices, limited supply, and fierce competition have made it tough for renters to become owners.
Shutterstock
Despite these hurdles, first-time purchasers remain persistent and even showed resilience through the pandemic years.
Statewide, the median home price stood around $382,500 in 2023, but this masks huge regional differences.
Affordability is a top concern for first-time buyers, who typically have lower incomes and savings than repeat buyers.
In New York City and some metro areas, many first-time buyers opt for apartments.
Co-operative apartments (co-ops) and condominiums are common starter homes in NYC.
Co-ops are usually 1040% cheaper than comparable condos in the city, making them attractive to budget-conscious first-timers.
Outside of New York City, many first-timers purchase homes in the low-to-mid six figures.
Location Preferences
Location preferences for first-time buyers often balance affordability with proximity to jobs or family.
Here the challenge is less about million-dollar price tags and more about finding quality inventory within budget.
When the pandemic hit in spring 2020, the housing market temporarily ground to a halt amid lockdowns.
However, by that summer, home sales rebounded sharply as pent-up demand was unleashed.
The Pandemic Housing Boom
What followed was an unprecedented housing boom.
Remote work became widespread, untethering many young professionals from their offices.
The data show first-time buyer activity actually held up well during 2020.
Changing Homebuyer Expectations
One interesting trend was first-time buyers upsizing their expectations.
Historically, a starter home might be a small condo or cottage.
In an effort to curb inflation, the Federal Reserve hiked rates aggressively, which sent mortgage costs soaring.
The Affordability Challenge
For first-time buyers, this was a game changer.
Many entry-level buyers had to lower their price range or pause their plans altogether.
The immediate effect in 2022 was a cooling of the housing market.
Home sales volume dropped sharply as buyer demand pulled back.
First-time buyers, in particular, felt the strain.
Adaptations to the New Reality
Those who remained in the market had to adjust their strategies.
Yet, even as conditions worsened for buyers, there were a few silver linings.
This meant the pool of buyers in 2023 skewed more towards those who didnt already own a home.
Persistent Inventory Challenges
However, regaining share did not mean an easy road.
New York States housing inventory sat near historic lows throughout 2023.
By late 2023, mortgage rates hit their peak around 7.8%, the highest in 23 years.
This was a brutal capstone to an already challenging period.
First-time buyer activity slowed but did not disappear.
The 20222023 period tested first-time buyers severely.
Many had to delay their purchase or compromise on their plans.
In NYC itself, condos and co-ops dominate first-time purchases.
Demographics of First-Time Buyers
The age of first-time buyers has been rising.
Nationally in 2023, the average first-time buyer was about 35 years old.
In terms of household composition, a majority of first-time buyers are couples.
However, a significant share of first-time buyers are single individuals.
Income is a critical demographic factor.
First-time buyers typically earn less than repeat buyers but still need a solid income to afford New York housing.
Nationally, recent first-time buyers had a median household income around $95,000.
In New York, particularly downstate, incomes often must be higher due to costs.
One notable trend is the increasing reliance on help to buy that first home.
Given high prices, many New York first-time buyers get financial assistance from family or first-time buyer programs.
SONYMA loans often come with down payment grants or forgivable second mortgages to cover closing expenses.
Recent Policy Initiatives
New York lawmakers also proposed new ideas.
Another legislative effort came in early 2025 with a bill to exempt first-time buyers from the mortgage recording tax.
During the pandemic, broader federal policies indirectly aided first-time buyers.
Conclusion
First-time homebuyers in New York State navigated a tumultuous five-year span from 2019 through 2023.
The first-time homebuying trends in New York from 2019 to 2023 tell a story of resilience amid challenges.
