The actress calls it one of her “all-time favorite recipes.”

Jake Sternquist

For many of us, Ina Garten’s recipes are the gold standard.

I’ve tried herChipotle-Cheddar Crackers,French Apple Tart, andBaked Shrimp Scampi, and all were 10/10.

Here’s what I thought and why the recipe wasn’t what I was expecting.

Here’s how to make a batch.

What Make Ina Garten’s Chicken Chili Recipe Special?

I can see why Jennifer enjoys this recipe forchicken chili.

A few ingredients set this recipe apart from other chilis we’ve tried.

The addition of fresh basil adds a subtle freshness that we loved.

However, we found the predominant flavor was bell pepper.

The seasonings are light and allow the savory chicken and vegetables to shine.

In a pinch, I think you could easily swap in canned tomato sauce or canned crushed tomatoes.

We all agreed it was the perfect cross between a tortilla soup and a chicken chili.

It’s definitely a brothy soup rather than athick stew.

Overall, many of us liked this recipe but wouldn’t rush to make it again.