(Hint: They should have these three key characteristics.)

If not, it’s time to go shopping and ensure your new ones do.

Test Kitchen Tip:Even if you have nonstick cookie sheets, lining them withparchment paperis a good idea.

sugar cookie dough baking sheet

Credit: Scott Little

It makes cookie removal and cleanup much easier.

Here are a few features to steer clear of when you’re looking for the best cookie sheets:

Peanut butter cookies on cookie sheet

Because this pan has four raised sides, it’s considered a baking sheet or jelly roll pan, not a cookie sheet. It is not the best choice for baking cookies.Credit: Andy Lyons